Care and Control Charge in Winnipeg

What does it mean to be charged with Care and Control?

Care and Control of a Motor VehicleBeing charged with care and control can be a surprising experience as it doesn’t require that you’re driving the vehicle to be charged. The charge can be laid when the police have reasonable grounds to believe that you are impaired and that your course of conduct associated with the vehicle creates a realistic risk of danger.

You can be charged with this offence if you are found in the driver’s seat, the passenger’s seat, anywhere in the vehicle, and even anywhere near the vehicle. You can be charged if found asleep in the vehicle, even if the key were not in the ignition and you had no intention to drive.

Imagine for a moment, you find yourself too drunk to drive home after being at the bar. You know you can’t drive home because you are too intoxicated, so you call a taxi and sit in your car to wait for the cab. It’s the middle of winter, so you turn on the engine to stay warm. You fall asleep and awake to the police knocking on your window. You get charged with care and control for having control of the motor vehicle while impaired.

This was the exact situation Mr. Boudeault found himself. This case took him all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada. The Supreme Court decided that normally being found drunk in a car while the engine is running is enough to be found guilty of care and control. However, when looking at the specific facts of Mr. Boudeault case, in that he had no intention of driving and had put a plan in place to get home by a taxi, the Court found him not guilty.


Care and Control Sentencing

The penalties for being convicted of care and control is every bit as severe as a conviction for impaired driving or driving with excess blood alcohol. You can face up to five years in jail. The offence also carries minimum sentences:

• A minimum fine of $1000 and a one year driving prohibition for a first conviction.
• A mandatory minimum jail sentence of 30 and a two year driving prohibition for a second conviction.
• A minimum jail sentence of 120 days and a three year driving prohibition for subsequent convictions.

In some cases, an offender being sentenced for care and control can be granted a “curative discharge”. In order to achieve this sentence, the court must be persuaded the offender is addicted to alcohol, and requires medical treatment to manage their addiction.


Defending Care and Control Charges

When preparing a defence for a care and control charge, it’s important to understand some basics. If you are found in the driver’s seat of the vehicle, there is a legal presumption you were in “care and control” of the vehicle. This presumption is set out in section 258(1)(a) of the Criminal Code as follows:

“where it is proved that the accused occupied the seat or position ordinarily occupied by a person who operates a motor vehicle, vessel or aircraft or any railway equipment or who assists in the operation of an aircraft or of railway equipment, the accused shall be deemed to have had the care or control of the vehicle, vessel, aircraft or railway equipment, as the case may be, unless the accused establishes that the accused did not occupy that seat or position for the purpose of setting the vehicle, vessel, aircraft or railway equipment in motion or assisting in the operation of the aircraft or railway equipment, as the case may be”

In cases where you are found in the diver’s seat, your defence lawyer will have to establish, through evidence at trial, an explanation for why you were in the driver’s seat, that had nothing to do with driving. Overcoming that hurdle, the Crown can still attempt to prove you had care and control in one of three ways:

  1. that you initially didn’t intend to drive, but may later have changed your mind while still impaired;
  2. that you may have unintentionally set the vehicle in motion; and,
  3. that through your negligence, bad judgment or otherwise, your stationary or inoperable vehicle may have endanger persons or property.

If the Crown succeeded in establishing any of these three reasons, like with the diver’s seat presumption, your defence lawyer will have to pursued the court otherwise. There can be a lot of different reasons why you were in vehicle while intoxicated. Like Mr. Boudeault, you might have had no intention to drive and only been trying to stay warm while waiting for a cab. Maybe knowing that your in no fit condition to drive, your intention was to sleep until you were sober enough to drive. Whatever your case, it’s important to consult with a lawyer before making a decision whether to plead guilty.


Related Impaired Driving Topics

  1. When can the police pull me over?
  2. What is the Licence Suspension Appeal Board?
  3. How much is the true cost of an impaired driving conviction?

Get a free consultation

Send Josh your case and your contact information to get a Free Initial consultation on how to proceed.